Hotels in Shelter Island

Enjoy your stay and find the best Hotels in Shelter Island at affordable prices

Searching for a hotel in Shelter Island (Florida)? You will find a wide selection of hotels in Shelter Island and the surrounding region at great rates, starting from $53.54 per night. From cheap budget hotels to family hotels and premium hotels for business travel and more upscale. Choose a hotel for more info about the offer.

Hotels in Shelter Island and region (40 miles)

Southampton Long Island Hotel

Hotel in Southampton near Shelter Island, Florida , 450 County Road 39

This Southampton property is located 3 miles from Coopers Beach and features an outdoor swimming pool.

Parking
Family rooms
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool

Very good 113 Reviews 8.1

from $360.00 Show details »

Sea Haven Resort Motel

Hotel in Southampton near Shelter Island, Florida , 62 Longview Road

Located in Southampton, within 2.9 km of Meschutt Beach and 28 km of Splish Splash, Sea Haven Resort Motel provides accommodation with a garden and fr...

Parking
Bath
TV
Air conditioning
Hairdryer

Good 31 Reviews 7.1

from $359.10 Show details »

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

Hotel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , Two Bridge Street

This 4-star eco-friendly hotel is located in historic Old Saybrook along the Connecticut River.

Parking
Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Sauna

Superb 334 Reviews 9.1

from $400.10 Show details »

Shorewood Inn

Motel in Jamesport near Shelter Island, Florida , 1399 Main Road

Set in Jamesport, within 2.1 km of South Jamesport Beach and 14 km of Splish Splash, Shorewood Inn offers accommodation with a garden and free WiFi th...

Parking
Pets allowed
Allergy-free room
Tea/Coffee maker
Shower

Good 208 Reviews 7.7

from $180.90 Show details »

Water's Edge Resort & Spa

Resort in Westbrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 1525 Boston Post Road

Featuring private beach access and scenic ocean views, this resort also has a luxury spa and an on-site restaurant.

Parking
Restaurant
Bar
Sauna
Fitness centre

Fabulous 411 Reviews 8.6

from $399.00 Show details »

PIER BLUE INN Old Saybrook - Essex

Hotel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 1430 Boston Post Road

Ideally situated off US Route 1, near I-95 in the city of Old Saybrook, Connecticut, Pier Blue Old Saybrook - Clinton is only a short distance from ma...

Parking
Pets allowed
Shower
Bath
TV

Good 798 Reviews 7.3

from $79.00 Show details »

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook -...

Motel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 1750 Boston Post Road

This Old Saybrook, Connecticut hotel is a 5-minute drive from Harvey’s Beach and the Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center.

Parking
Pets allowed

Pleasant 105 Reviews 6.3

from $85.03 Show details »

Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook

Hotel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 37 Spencer Plain Road

Positioned just off Interstate 95, only a short drive from Foxwoods Casino, this Old Saybrook, Connecticut motel provides comfortable accommodations a...

Parking
Family rooms
Tea/Coffee maker
Shower
Bath

Pleasant 359 Reviews 6.3

from $89.00 Show details »

Liberty Inn Old Saybrook

Motel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 55 Springbrook Road

This Old Saybrook motel is near the Connecticut River and Long Island Sound.

Parking
Pets allowed

Good 235 Reviews 7.4

from $89.00 Show details »

Clinton Motel

Motel in Clinton near Shelter Island, Florida , 163 East Main Street

Set in Clinton, within 1.5 km of Clinton Town Beach and 30 km of Goodspeed Opera House, Clinton Motel offers accommodation with barbecue facilities an...

Parking
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool
Tea/Coffee maker

Very good 220 Reviews 8.0

from $98.00 Show details »

Shore Road Inn

Motel in Lyme Station near Shelter Island, Florida , 436 Shore Road

Set in Lyme Station, 32 km from Mystic Seaport, Shore Road Inn features express check-in and check-out and free WiFi.

Parking
Pets allowed
Allergy-free room

Very good 20 Reviews 8.1

from $151.33 Show details »

Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

Hotel in Old Saybrook near Shelter Island, Florida , 100 Essex Road

Quality Inn Old Saybrook is located 900 metres from the US Coast Guard Auxiliary.

Parking
Bar
Fitness centre
Indoor pool
Swimming pool

Good 465 Reviews 7.3

from $112.80 Show details »

Bayview Resort

Resort in Hampton Bays near Shelter Island, Florida , 53 W Tiana Road Hampton Bays

Offering an outdoor pool overlooking the Tiana Bay and a fitness centre, Bayview Resort is located in Hampton Bays.

Parking
Fitness centre
Family rooms
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool

Good 117 Reviews 8.0

from $272.25 Show details »

Colonial Shores Resort

Motel in Hampton Bays near Shelter Island, Florida , 83 W Tiana Road

Situated in Hampton Bays, 24 km from Splish Splash, Colonial Shores Resort features accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private ...

Parking
Family rooms
Outdoor pool
Kids' outdoor play equipment
Swimming pool

Fabulous 122 Reviews 8.9

from $235.00 Show details »

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 451 East Main Street

Located on the Peconic River, this hotel boasts both indoor and outdoor pools and a full service marina.

Parking
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre
Family rooms

Fabulous 485 Reviews 8.6

from $263.12 Show details »

Budget Host East End Hotel in Riverhead

Motel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 30 Lake Avenue

Located in Suffolk County, this Riverhead motel is 5 minutes’ drive from hiking and fishing at Indian Island County Park and the Francis S.

Parking
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool
TV

Pleasant 244 Reviews 6.0

from $103.50 Show details »

Sun and Sound Montauk

Hotel in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida , 22 Soudview Drive

Located in Eastern Long Island, this Montauk resort offers free Wi-Fi and accommodations that include a fully equipped kitchen.

Parking
Family rooms
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool

Fabulous 135 Reviews 8.9

from $410.81 Show details »

Sole East Beach

Motel in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida , 107 South Emerson Avenue

Just across the street from the beach, this stylish motel features light, air-conditioned rooms with HD cable TVs and luxury Aveda toiletries.

Parking
Pets allowed
Family rooms
Kid meals

Pleasant 70 Reviews 6.6

from $229.00 Show details »

Aderi Hotel Near Casino

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 239 Flanders Road

Featuring 3-star accommodation, Aderi Hotel Near Casino is set in Niantic, 34 km from Foxwoods Casinos and 39 km from Goodspeed Opera House.

Parking
Fitness centre
Family rooms
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool

Passable 54 Reviews 5.0

from $82.80 Show details »

Swiss Motel

Motel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 1273 West Main Street

This central Riverhead motel is just 2 miles from Atlantis Marine World.

Parking
Family rooms

Pleasant 126 Reviews 6.4

from $135.67 Show details »

Sleep Inn & Suites

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 5 King Arthur Drive

Located off Interstate 95, this Niantic, Connecticut hotel serves a daily continental breakfast and offers rooms with free Wi-Fi and a cable TV.

Parking
Fitness centre
Indoor pool
Kid-friendly buffet
Swimming pool

Good 431 Reviews 7.7

from $92.65 Show details »

Motel 6-Niantic, CT - New London

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 269 Flanders Road

Located close to Interstate 95 and Interstate 395, this Niantic motel offers - Free wireless high-speed Internet access and rooms that feature a seati...

Pets allowed

Pleasant 380 Reviews 6.2

from $75.99 Show details »

Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long...

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 2012 Old Country Road

Situated in Riverhead, 2.4 km from Splish Splash, Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long Island East End features accommodation with free bikes, free...

Parking
Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre

Very good 242 Reviews 8.2

from $269.10 Show details »

Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 2038 Old Country Road

Situated across the street from the Tanger Outlet Mall, on Long Islands city of Riverhead, New York, this hotel offers comfortable guestrooms and an o...

Parking
Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre

Good 545 Reviews 8.0

from $222.88 Show details »

Hotel Indigo East End, an IHG Hotel

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 1830 West Main Street, Route 25

This Long Island hotel is located just 800 metres from the Tanger Outlet Mall.

Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre
Spa and wellness centre

Very good 220 Reviews 8.5

from $208.61 Show details »

Number of Hotels in Shelter Island	62
Number of guest ratings	94
Average price per night	$347.63
Lowest price per night	$53.54
Highest price per night	$5.195.00

Most popular Hotels in Shelter Island

The most popular Hotels in Shelter Island based on average guest rating (Top 10).

Cheapest Hotels in Shelter Island

The cheapest Hotels in Shelter Island based on room rate per night (Top 10).

Most booked Hotels in Shelter Island

The most booked Hotels in Shelter Island based on popularity with guests (Top 10).

How to find the best hotel in Shelter Island (Florida)

Finding the best hotel in Shelter Island depends on your individual needs and preferences. First, consider your budget. Deciding how much you are willing to spend can help you narrow down your search and avoid overspending. Keep in mind that higher prices may not always equate to better quality or value.

Next, think about the location. Do you want to stay in the heart of Shelter Island, or would you prefer a quieter area outside of town? Consider factors like proximity to attractions, transportation, and safety when choosing a location.

After that, consider the type of hotel you want to stay in. Do you prefer a boutique hotel with personalized service, or a large chain hotel with more amenities? Think about whats most important to you, whether it is a pool, a gym, or a great restaurant.

It is also important to read reviews from other travelers to get an idea of the hotels reputation. Look for comments about cleanliness, service, and overall experience to get a better sense of what to expect.

Don't be afraid to contact the hotel directly with any questions or concerns. A good hotel should be happy to answer your questions and make your stay as comfortable as possible.

Hotels in Shelter Island - which one to choose?

One of the most common types of hotels in Shelter Island and surrounding region are budget or economy hotels, who offer affordable accommodation for travelers on a tight budget, and extended-stay hotels, which are designed for guests who need to stay for an extended period of time, such as business travelers or those relocating to a new city.

Another popular type of hotel is the boutique hotel. These hotels are smaller in size and typically feature unique and personalized decor and amenities, often designed to appeal to a specific target market or theme. Boutique hotels in Shelter Island are often independently owned and operated, and they are known for their distinctive character and personalized service.

If you want the carefree package maybe the luxury hotel in Shelter Island ist the right choice for you. These hotels are known for their high-end amenities and exceptional service, and are often located in prime locations such as city centers or scenic destinations. Luxury hotels typically feature upscale restaurants, fitness centers, spas, and other lavish facilities, and they are designed to cater to guests who are seeking a luxurious and indulgent experience.

Resort hotels are another common type of accommodation, particularly in tropical and beach destinations. These hotels offer a wide range of amenities, including pools, spas, restaurants, and outdoor activities such as water sports and golf. They are designed to provide guests with a complete vacation experience, with everything they need to relax and have fun in one location.

Check availability