Accommodations in Shelter Island (Page 3)

Enjoy your stay and find the best accommodations in Shelter Island at affordable prices

Searching for an accommodation in Shelter Island (Florida)? You will find a various number of lodgings for your overnight stay in Shelter Island, starting from $79 per bed and night. Whether you are looking for a hotel, a guesthouse or an apartment, you will find an accommodation that meets your needs.

Accommodations in Shelter Island and region (30 miles)

Inn at Harbor Hill Marina

B&B in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 60 Grand Street

Located on the Niantic River shore, this Connecticut bed and breakfast features a breakfast buffet and free Wi-Fi.

Parking
Family rooms

Exceptional 228 Reviews 9.5

from $399.00 Show details »

Scranton Seahorse Inn

B&B in Madison near Shelter Island, Florida , 818 Boston Post Road

Featuring complimentary bicycle rentals, this Madison, Connecticut bed and breakfast features a coffee room with complimentary drinks and snacks.

Parking

Superb 67 Reviews 9.1

from $270.22 Show details »

The Griswold Inn

Inn in Essex near Shelter Island, Florida , 36 MAIN ST

The Griswold Inn has a garden, shared lounge, a terrace and bar in Essex.

Parking
Restaurant
Bar
Family rooms
Kid meals

Very good 256 Reviews 8.6

from $250.00 Show details »

Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps to Rive...

Apartment in Essex near Shelter Island, Florida

Situated in Essex, 18 km from Goodspeed Opera House, 35 km from Wesleyan University and 45 km from Thimble Islands, Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps t...

Parking

Exceptional 1 Reviews 10.0

from $408.00 Show details »

Copper Beech Inn

Inn in Ivoryton near Shelter Island, Florida , 46 Main Street

Built in 1889, this hotel is located in the scenic Lower Connecticut River Valley, within the historic town of Essex.

Parking
Restaurant
Bar
Spa and wellness centre
Kid meals

Very good 204 Reviews 8.2

from $209.00 Show details »

Budget Host East End Hotel in Riverhead

Motel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 30 Lake Avenue

Located in Suffolk County, this Riverhead motel is 5 minutes’ drive from hiking and fishing at Indian Island County Park and the Francis S.

Parking
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool
TV

Pleasant 244 Reviews 6.0

from $103.50 Show details »

Montauk Surf by the Sound

Holiday home in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida

Montauk Surf by the Sound is situated in Montauk, 2.1 km from Gin Beach, and features a patio, garden, and free WiFi.

Parking

no reviews

from $444.29 Show details »

The Homestead

B&B in Madison near Shelter Island, Florida , 391 Boston Post Road

Situated in Madison, 21 km from Thimble Islands and 28 km from City Hall, The Homestead features accommodation with free WiFi, air conditioning, free ...

Parking
Pets allowed
Family rooms
Breakfast in the room
Allergy-free room

Exceptional 120 Reviews 9.6

from $375.00 Show details »

Sun and Sound Montauk

Hotel in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida , 22 Soudview Drive

Located in Eastern Long Island, this Montauk resort offers free Wi-Fi and accommodations that include a fully equipped kitchen.

Parking
Family rooms
Swimming pool
Swimming Pool

Fabulous 135 Reviews 8.9

from $410.81 Show details »

The Ivoryton Inn

Inn in Ivoryton near Shelter Island, Florida , 115 Main Street

Featuring a garden, shared lounge, terrace and free WiFi, The Ivoryton Inn is located in Ivoryton, 16 km from Goodspeed Opera House and 32 km from Wes...

Parking
Tea/Coffee maker
Minibar
Shower
TV

Okay 47 Reviews 5.9

from $143.75 Show details »

Sole East Beach

Motel in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida , 107 South Emerson Avenue

Just across the street from the beach, this stylish motel features light, air-conditioned rooms with HD cable TVs and luxury Aveda toiletries.

Parking
Pets allowed
Family rooms
Kid meals

Pleasant 70 Reviews 6.6

from $229.00 Show details »

Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Apartment in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida , 126 S EMERSON AVE Floor 2 Suite 238

Located 500 metres from Kirk Park Beach, Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort offers accommodation in Montauk.

Parking
Restaurant
Bar
Family rooms
Outdoor pool

Fabulous 37 Reviews 8.6

from $485.00 Show details »

Aderi Hotel Near Casino

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 239 Flanders Road

Featuring 3-star accommodation, Aderi Hotel Near Casino is set in Niantic, 34 km from Foxwoods Casinos and 39 km from Goodspeed Opera House.

Parking
Fitness centre
Family rooms
Outdoor pool
Swimming pool

Passable 54 Reviews 5.0

from $82.80 Show details »

Swiss Motel

Motel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 1273 West Main Street

This central Riverhead motel is just 2 miles from Atlantis Marine World.

Parking
Family rooms

Pleasant 126 Reviews 6.4

from $135.67 Show details »

Sleep Inn & Suites

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 5 King Arthur Drive

Located off Interstate 95, this Niantic, Connecticut hotel serves a daily continental breakfast and offers rooms with free Wi-Fi and a cable TV.

Parking
Fitness centre
Indoor pool
Kid-friendly buffet
Swimming pool

Good 431 Reviews 7.7

from $92.65 Show details »

Montauk Private Getaway

Holiday home in Montauk near Shelter Island, Florida

Montauk Private Getaway is situated in Montauk, 1.7 km from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, and features a balcony, garden, and free WiFi.

Parking

no reviews

from $200.57 Show details »

Motel 6-Niantic, CT - New London

Hotel in Niantic near Shelter Island, Florida , 269 Flanders Road

Located close to Interstate 95 and Interstate 395, this Niantic motel offers - Free wireless high-speed Internet access and rooms that feature a seati...

Pets allowed

Pleasant 380 Reviews 6.2

from $75.99 Show details »

Greenview Inn Riverhead

Inn in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 1433 W Main Street

Greenview Inn Riverhead is situated in Riverhead along the Peconic River, 2 km from Tanger Outlets Riverhead and amidst Long Island Wine Country.

Parking
Shower
Telephone
Air conditioning
Refrigerator

Passable 176 Reviews 5.2

from $139.00 Show details »

Remodeled Farmhouse in Waterford Near 2...

Holiday home in Waterford near Shelter Island, Florida

Remodeled Farmhouse in Waterford Near 2 Beaches! is set in Waterford, 19 km from Mystic Seaport, 28 km from Foxwoods Casinos, and 45 km from Goodspeed...

Parking
Pets allowed
Internet facilities
Hairdryer
Iron

Exceptional 4 Reviews 9.8

from $337.00 Show details »

Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long...

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 2012 Old Country Road

Situated in Riverhead, 2.4 km from Splish Splash, Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long Island East End features accommodation with free bikes, free...

Parking
Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre

Very good 242 Reviews 8.2

from $269.10 Show details »

Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 2038 Old Country Road

Situated across the street from the Tanger Outlet Mall, on Long Islands city of Riverhead, New York, this hotel offers comfortable guestrooms and an o...

Parking
Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre

Good 545 Reviews 8.0

from $222.88 Show details »

Riverwind Inn Bed and Breakfast

B&B in Deep River near Shelter Island, Florida , 209 Main Street

This 19th century Connecticut bed and breakfast offers rooms with antique style furnishings and architectural detailing with modern convenience such a...

Parking

Exceptional 24 Reviews 9.9

from $225.00 Show details »

Hotel Indigo East End, an IHG Hotel

Hotel in Riverhead near Shelter Island, Florida , 1830 West Main Street, Route 25

This Long Island hotel is located just 800 metres from the Tanger Outlet Mall.

Restaurant
Pets allowed
Bar
Fitness centre
Spa and wellness centre

Very good 220 Reviews 8.5

from $208.61 Show details »

Comfort Inn Guilford near I-95

Hotel in Guilford near Shelter Island, Florida , 300 Boston Post Road

Just off Interstate 95, the 100 percent non-smoking Comfort Inn hotel is close to many local points of interest like Hammonasset Beach State Park.

Parking
Allergy-free room
Electric vehicle charging station
Tea/Coffee maker
Shower

Good 263 Reviews 7.9

from $108.25 Show details »

New London Hideaway Near Beaches and Loc...

Apartment in New London near Shelter Island, Florida

Situated in New London, 17 km from Mystic Seaport, 25 km from Foxwoods Casinos and 47 km from Goodspeed Opera House, New London Hideaway by Beaches an...

Parking

Exceptional 7 Reviews 9.9

from $413.67 Show details »

Number of Accommodations in Shelter Island	96
Number of guest ratings	94
Average price per night	$475.53
Lowest price per night	$79.00
Highest price per night	$5.195.00

Most popular accommodations in Shelter Island

The most popular accommodations in Shelter Island based on average guest rating (Top 10).

Cheapest accommodations in Shelter Island

The cheapest accommodations in Shelter Island based on room rate per night (Top 10).

Most booked accommodations in Shelter Island

The most booked accommodations in Shelter Island based on popularity with guests (Top 10).

Sleep & Travel in Shelter Island (Florida)

Getting the best travel and overnight stay experience requires careful planning and attention to detail. Start by researching your destination and choosing the right accommodations for your needs and budget. Consider factors such as location, amenities, and reviews from other travelers. To make the most of your trip, take the time to explore Shelter Island and immerse yourself in the local culture. This might include trying new foods, visiting historic sites, or attending cultural events.

When booking your accommodation in Shelter Island, be sure to communicate any special requests or preferences you may have, such as a specific room type or dietary restrictions. This will help ensure that your stay is comfortable and enjoyable. Also don't forget to pack wisely and bring along any necessary travel essentials, such as comfortable shoes, sunscreen, and a camera to capture all of your memories. With careful planning and a spirit of adventure, you can have an unforgettable travel and overnight stay experience.

How to find the best accommodation in Shelter Island

To find the perfect place to stay in Shelter Island, consider your budget, preferred location, and the amenities you need. Do you want to stay in a hotel or a vacation rental or do your prefer an apartment or house with more space, privacy, and the opportunity to live like a local? Do you need access to a kitchen, laundry facilities, or a gym? Research online reviews and ratings to get an idea of what past guests have experienced. Also, consider the type of trip you're taking. If you're traveling with family, you may need a larger space or a kid-friendly environment. If you're on a romantic getaway, you may want a more intimate setting.

Check availability